Watts, Heat and Light : Measuring The Heat Output of Different Lamps

This experiment was intended to measure the way in which different “types” of lamps of the same wattage produce drastically different basking temperatures.

Introduction

One of the basic laws of physics is the law of the Conservation of Energy. This simply states that energy cannot be created or destroyed, it can only be transferred from one form to another. So when a 100watt lamp is switched on, 100 watts of electrical energy is converted to 100watts of light and heat; a 50watt lamp produces a total 50 watts of light and heat, and so on.*  However, some lamps are more efficient at producing light than others; this determines how much of that 100 watts is transformed into light, and how much is "wasted" and comes out as heat (very useful, though, if what we want is a basking lamp).

An incandescent lamp is an extremely inefficient light source. According to the Wikipedia online encyclopaedia, a 100 watt bulb is 2.1% efficient. In other words, it produces about 2 watts of light and 98 watts of heat.

A halogen lamp is a bit better. For every 100 watts you put in, you get about 3.5 watts of light and 96.5 watts of heat.

Fluorescent lamps are said to be about 8.2% efficient, and although there were no figures on Wikipedia for mercury vapour lamps, I found one reference saying they were about as efficient as fluorescent lamps, and another that said they were three times as efficient as incandescent lamps... so we're looking at 6 - 8% efficiency here. 100 watts of electricity will be converted to, at most 8 watts of light (including UV light) and 92% will still come out as heat.

So the main factors which determine how much heat a lamp puts out, are what type of lamp it is, and its wattage.

However, the heat and light from a lamp can be emitted in all directions, or focused on a small area (consider the heat and light you might experience sitting 2ft below a 60 watt frosted "globe" lamp as opposed to a 60 watt narrow beam spot lamp) hence the shape of the lamp, the type of glass surface and the presence or absence of reflectors, such are found inside spot lamps, will also play a major part in determining how hot a basking spot gets directly under any lamp, of whatever wattage.

The Experiment.

In this experiment we used a “heat collector” that consisted of a small metal disc painted flat black. This is the most efficient form of material to absorb the light and heat energy. This was placed on top of a white styrofoam block that would not absorb much heat. This was positioned at 12” (30cm) from the light source.

We collected data at 2, 5 and 10 minutes using an infra-red "temperature gun". We also took temperature readings at the base of the fixture to see how much heat energy was being lost out the back of the lamps. The fixtures were allowed to cool before the next set of readings were recorded.

Understand that the temperatures reported do not necessarily represent the actual temperatures you may find in your vivarium, produced by the lamps listed, because different materials will reflect and absorb heat at different rates. The small black metal discs we used will absorb heat differently, and give different results, from a light brown basking log, or white sand, or a living reptile body. Living creatures will disperse heat through their body according to mass. Always triple check basking area temperatures before allowing any reptiles to be exposed to new lamps.

Results

 MAKE WATTS TYPE of BULB TEMP (°F) @ 12" TEMP (°F) of Lamp Fixture 2 min 5 min 10 min 2 min 5 min 10min ZooMed 150 Infra-red Spot 149 159 171 77 80 82 ZooMed 160 MV Flood 'Powersun' 96 106 115 85 95 102 Westron 160 MV Flood 'MegaRay SB' 98 112 128 74 77 84 ESU 150 Incandescent 'Nocturnal BL' 143 164 165 100 118 118 ESU 150 Incandescent 'Brightlight' 191 209 218 75 77 79 ZooMed 150 Flood 'Basking Lamp' 181 186 195 105 114 123 ZooMed 100 MV Flood 'Powersun' 118 131 136 98 116 118 T Rex 100 MV Spot 'Active UV Heat' 93 114 136 84 102 113 ESU 100 Incandescent 'Nightlight' 134 150 152 78 80 83 ESU 100 Incandescent 'Brightlight' 165 188 194 77 79 81 ACE 100 Halogen Flood 205 226 226 77 82 86 ZooMed 100 Ceramic Heat Emitter 101 127 140 75 99 104 GE 100 Halogen Spot Lamp 158 257 271 75 82 87 GE 100 Halogen Flood Lamp 128 178 187 74 86 88 GE 75 Incandescent Spot 'Black Light' 92 101 103 89 96 97 GE 60 Incandescent 'Black Light' 102 109 112 93 94 105 GE 60 Incandescent Clear Glass 169 176 178 75 81 86 Westron 60 Inline MV Flood Lamp 95 97 103 90 93 98 Westron 60 Inline MV Spot Lamp 130 146 150 Westron 60 Heat Emitter 98 112 130 77 79 80 GE 50 Halogen Spot Lamp 185 193 196 76 85 88 GE 50 Halogen Flood Lamp 123 138 141 74 78 81